Game of Thrones: Chapter 15: Sansa AKA Awkward 1st Date

This chapter opens up with Sansa having breakfast with Septa Mordane. She is all set to spend the day traveling the King’s Road south to the capital riding in style with Queen Cersei and Princess Marcella in the royal wheelhouse.  Notably absent is Arya who was also invited. Early on it’s clear that Sansa is already smitten with her betrothed Joffrey. She is a bit worried that Arya might spoil the occasion as she tends to be less of a lady and more of a tomboyish sort. After finishing her breakfast she eventually finds Arya by the banks of the Trident with her direwolf dressed in leathers. Sansa tells her sister she is expected to travel with the queen today and Arya flat out refuses. She says her and a friend Mycah are going to spend the day looking for rubies that were knocked off the armor of Rhaegar Targaryen when King Robert killed him during the rebellion.

Here we see a lot of the differences in the mentalities of the two Stark girls. While Sansa is concerned about appearances, decorum and possibly the opportunity to spend a bit of time with the prince she is to wed and somewhat head over heels for, Araya has no interest in any of that.

Arya by comparison seem to have a much better working knowledge of recent history. Sansa had no idea what rubies Arya was referring to when she told her older sister what her plans for the day were. Arya is also not concerned about offending the queen by not showing up as expected. She has more of a free will and is less likely to worry about what others may think as opposed to Sansa who is very much into keeping up appearances.

I think even more telling is that Sansa doesn’t take the time to look upon the land and get to know it as Arya has. To her it’s just one field, farm and holdfast after another. She doesn’t really see the nuances of the land like Arya appreciates. Arya points out that she found 36 types of flowers she never had seen prior as well as relating she had seen wild horse herds as well as a haunted watchtower and she and her friend also found a lizard-lion.

Another difference in the two is the way in which they react to their father's instructions to stay with the column. Sansa dutifully obeys while Arya reasons that as they dont travel very far and has her direwolf Nymeria to protect her.

Sansa also by admission hates riding and even more hates the situation as the journey through the swampy area known as the Neck was unpleasant to her. Arya on the other hand enjoyed it and even seems to be relishing the opportunity to explore and discover more of the world she lives in.

Another great difference between the two is that Arya seems to be making friends and getting to know the people she is traveling with. Sansa can’t understand this mentality and even notes that Arya’s friend Mycah, the son of a butcher, is terrible as he stinks of meat from the chopping block and can hardly stand the sight of him. Yet Arya has a genuine friendship and enjoys his company.

One thing that Sansa noted at bedtime is that Arya has bruises and welts on her arms, shoulders. This suggests she either has had some rough times exploring or has found someone to practice her swordsmanship with.

The two end in a sort of typical fashion of Arya saying she is gonna go off and do her own thing while Sansa tries to make her jealous by saying that they are gonna have a wonderful time relaxing, and traveling in style and luxury.

While Arya seems to be fine with this Sansa is a bit hurt as she doesn't understand why Arya can’t do what is expected of her and act like a proper lady. To Sansa where decorum and etiquette as well as appearances are things that matter a great deal, Arya’s complete disregard for such things and even outright rude manner on occasion reflects badly upon her. After all the Starks are the the nobility of the North and Arya seems to act like a commoner as opposed to someone who is highborn.

As she returns to camp she notices a crowd has gathered and as she gets closer she sees Cersei greeting a group of knights who had been sent by the council. We learn that King Robert has gone off hunting and thus the queen is there to welcome them. One of the knights is older and dressed in white while the younger one has a helm with decorative antlers upon it. The third knight's appearance Sansa finds scary and she actually physically shakes when he feels her looking at her and turns his gaze upon her.

The Hound Sandor Clegane sets his hands upon her shoulders and Sansa mistakes it for the reassuring touch of her father. So when she turns and sees Sandors burned face she momentarily loses composure.

The two new knights notice Lady and are quite taken back. Sandor makes a rather crude joke about the Starks using them for wet nurses which gets a few chuckles from the starring members of the crowd.

Cersei at this moment prompts Joffrey to go to the aid of his betrothed. It’s noteworthy that Joffrey didn’t actually think to go himself but needed to be told to go show some compassion and assist his wife to be. Joffrey sends the Hound away and Sansa says it was one of the other knights and not the Hound who unnerved her.

As it turns out that knight is Ser Ilyn Payne who is the royal executioner. Sansa quips they got the right man for the job after Cersei says people should fear the man appointed as the King’s Justice. This actually gets laughs from the crowd and Sansa seems to regain her composure.

The elder knight introduces himself as Ser Barristan Selmy of the Kingsguard. Sansa having regained her composure, is able to carry herself as would be expected and replies that she is honored to meet the living legend Barristan the Bold. The younger knight makes a joke at Selmy’s expense calling him “Barristan the Old”  and tests Sansa to guess who he is.

Sansa correctly deduces that the man before him is Renly Baratheon as he bears a stag upon his sigil, golden antlers on his helmet and notes his “extreme youth”. Barristan takes this chance to return the good natured joking by saying by Renly’s extreme youth he’s a prancing jackanapes. Again this gets a good laugh out of those gathered including Renly who takes the jest in stride as Barristan did.  

So with a bit of composure and humor the almost disastrous situation for Sansa is averted. Sansa even apologizes to Ser Ilyn who doesn’t reply. Joffrey lets her know that he had his tongue ripped out by the former king. Sansa also then learns that plans to travel with the queen and princess will have to wait as the queen will have to tend to matters of state.

The queen does however ask Prince Joffrey to entertain Sansa for the day and Joffrey replies he would be happy to. This is almost a dream come true for Sansa. She is absolutely over the moon with this turn of events. She even starts thinking that Joffrey came to her rescue a few moments ago like some fanciful tale of legends where a hero saves a damsel in distress.

Joffrey suggests going riding and Sansa says she loves to go riding. This of course is the absolute opposite of what she said to Arya, but the chance to spend time with Joffrey is worth it to her.

They leave Lady and Sandor behind and Joffrey assures her that he can protect her with his blade Lion’s Tooth if it comes to it. The two of them go out and explore some caves, track a shadowcat and end up finding a holdfast where the prince makes the residents provide them with food and wine. As they continue on Joffrey leads them towards where the battle of the Trident was fought and recounts the tale of how his father became king.

They hear sounds coming from nearby and while Sansa wants to go back Joffrey wants to go and see what it is. As it turns out it’s Arya and Mycah playing with broomstick handles pretending they are dueling swords. Joffrey laughs when Arya gets struck on the hand and drops her stick, and this gets the two of them noticed.

Joffrey taunts Mycah while holding his steel blade and challenges him. Mycah is obviously scared and protests he doesn't have a ‘real sword’ and that Arya asked him to practice. Joffrey takes this chance to bully the boy and sets the tip of his blade to Mycah’s face and draws blood.

Arya yells for Joffrey to stop, and Joffrey says he won’t hurt the butcher's boy, and then adds the word “much” rather menacingly.

Again the differences between the two Stark girls is highlighted. Sansa who was using her words and calling for Arya to stay out of it is ignored as Arya decides she isn’t going to allow her helpless friend be hurt by the prince who is wielding a steel blade. Arya cracks Joffrey in the back of the head which gives Mycah a chance to flee the situation.

Joffrey turns his blade on Arya, disarms her and backs her up to a tree. Again Sansa is somewhat helpless in this situation and just yells for the two of them to stop, but her words aren’t heeded. Arya doesn’t have much of a choice in the matter and Joffrey is enraged and yelling curses at Arya.

Fortunately Nymeria comes to the rescue of Arya before anything bad happens. She knocks Joffrey to the ground, disarming him. Again Sansa is unsure what to do and is somewhat helpless as an onlooker, but Arya who is showing she is a person who takes action spares Joffrey by calling Nymeria to her.

While Joffrey is on the ground bleeding from his arm Arya goes and picks up his sword, she stands over him and delivers what I think is one of the best lines from any character in the book to this point..

Arya “She didn’t hurt you… much.”

This reduces the prince to whimpering and he begs for her not to hurt him and that he will tell his mother. Sansa screams for Arya to leave Joffrey alone and for once Arya listens. Prior to getting on her horse and riding off with her direwolf Arya tosses the princes blade into the river.

Sansa runs to her betrothed and tries to comfort him saying she will ride to the holdfast and get help for him. Joffrey looks at her with loathing and contempt and yells at her to go and not to touch him.

This is the first chapter we see through the point of view of Sansa. Prior we got her in chapters but mostly the interaction was from the point of view of her little sister Arya. We now get the full view.

Even here we still see that while they are vastly different they both have some things in common. Sansa and Arya are both with their wolves seemingly constantly, and both the wolves seem to be direct reflections of the Stark girls. Sansa’s direwolf Lady is just that and quite domesticated, while Arya’s wolf Nymeria is first seen in this chapter all muddy and not enjoying being brushed out in a very similar way to how Sansa views Arya who had been wearing the same riding leathers for the past few days. Both wolves are there and seem to come to the defense of the owners in times of need. Sansa when she grew fearful of Ser Payne and Arya when Joffrey was attacking her.

This is also the first situation where we see Joffrey having a truly cruel nature as opposed to just being a bit of an ass. It’s noticeable that he had to be prompted by the queen to go to the aid of Sansa when she lost her composure. Further Joffrey demonstrates his lack of maturity when he whimpers before Arya threatening to tell his mother. This is all in direct contrast to his behavior prior when he was boasting about carrying a real blade instead of a practice blade as he mocked Sasna’s brother Robb back at Winterfell.

From a storytelling perspective this sets up Sansa to look somewhat helpless and to be little more than a young girl with a crush on prince Joffrey. Indeed she does project things on him that simply aren’t true. This again is understandable as Sansa has grown up as a noble and really judging things from appearances as opposed to looking deeper to see things as they really are.

Her assumptions regarding the lands they travel through, the common folk as well as her negative opinion of Mycah based on his station in life all point to her not really having a good understanding of the world and the people in it. Yet ironically enough she is remarkably perceptive in determining who Renly is and recalls the history, titles and offices of Barristan the Bold. So this suggests she does have a good head on her shoulders but is just focused in an entirely different area than her sister is.

Of course Sansa is absolutely out of her element when swords are drawn. Fighting and violence are things Sansa was never expected to engage in let alone be able to put a stop to.

Lastly I'd like to point out one final thing that will become a greater theme as the story progresses which was introduced by Renly and that is ageism. While it was just a jest about Ser Barristan calling him Barristan the Old this is something that will show up again with some level of significance.

Game of Thrones: Chapter 14: Catelyn AKA Mothers Maddness

This chapter opens up with Catelyn still sitting by Brands side. It has been about 3 weeks since he fell and 8 days since Ned and everyone else left. Maester Luwin comes in to have her attend to the affairs of running Winterfell and she just gets upset and ends up shouting at Luwin without realizing it. Fortunately Robb arrives and lets Luwin know he will handle the books and decide who should be appointed to the positions left vacant by the departure of a good number of servants with Ned to King's Landing. We also learn that Catelyn has apparently in her sadness and despair over Bran's fall lost her senses. In addition to neglecting her duties and spending every moment with Bran she didn’t bother to see her husband and rest of the family off when they left. She also doesn’t trust Maester Luwin's assurances that Bran isn’t going to die, and has been ignoring her youngest son Rikkon.

Robb opens the window to let some air into the stuffy room and hearing the direwolves howl, and everything that has occurred is just overwhelming to her. I think it safe to assume she is having some sort of breakdown at this point.

This scene also offers a bit of insight about Robb. He seems to have an innate understanding that Bran hearing the howling will somehow help. In addition he can tell the differences between the wolves howls. He also quickly picks up on the fact that on this night the dogs joined in the howling and notes it’s unusual as they haven't done that before.

He also shows his concern as he helps his mother to the small bed and makes her promise him to get some sleep. Robb goes to close the window and notices the library tower is on fire and quickly sets off to fetch men to deal with it.

Catelyn closes the shutters window and when she turns around a stranger is in the room with her. The man is filthy and has a dagger in his hand. Quickly she realizes he’s here to kill Bran. She turns back to the window to call out for help but the stranger puts a hand over her mouth and brings his blade to her throat. Catelyn grabs the blade with her hand cutting deep into her fingers and bites the hand over her mouth. The stranger tosses her to the ground and is about to make a move when Brans wolf comes into the room, leaps knocking the attacker down and tears out his throat.

With that done the wolf then licks the blood off Catelyn's injured hand and then leaps up on the bed with Bran and lays down. If she wasn’t having a breakdown of some sort before this is easily the point because she starts to laugh hysterically.

NOTE: Some people have asked me how the Direwolf was able to open the doors to get to where Bran was and how it knew the assassin was going after Bran. First when Robb left the tower he more than likely didn’t bother to close the doors behind him in his haste. Not to mention the Catspaw/assassin was most likely trying to remain quiet, do the job quickly and make good his escape. So it’s unlikely he bothered to close the doors behind him as well. Further he didn’t expect Catelyn to remain with Bran.

The Catspaw: “You weren’t s’posed to be here,” he muttered sourly. “No one was s’posed to be here.”

Lastly the assassin had the stink of horses from where he had been hiding in the stables so even if there was no supernatural connection between the wolf and Bran, his scent would have easily been picked up by Bran's wolf.    

She is taken out of the room with Bran and to her own chambers where her wounds are tended to and she is put to bed and finally sleeps.. For four days..

When she wakes up Robb, Theon, the new captain of the guard Hallis Mollen and Rodrik Cassel, the Master at Arms of Winterfell discuss the events of the attack. Collectively they figure out the following.

• The assassin showed up with the king's party and was hiding out in the stables
• The killer was paid 90 silver stags and given a valyrian dagger with a dragonbone hilt for the job of killing Bran
• The fire in the library was set as a distraction and the assumption is someone wants Bran dead to keep him silent.
• Catlyn also reveals her sisters belief that the Lannisters killed Jon Arryn and recalls that Jaime Lannister didn’t go out on the hunt with the king on the day Bran fell. She speculates that Bran was actually thrown.

At the end of the discussion it is decided that Catelyn and Ser Rodrik will travel to King's Landing by riding to White Harbor and then travel via ship with hopes of getting to the capital quickly and unnoticed.

I opted to call this narrative on the Chapter "Mother's Madness" as this really is where Catelyn starts to crack and breakdown. While completely understandable her concern for her injured son, the additional physical and mental burden she places upon herself by not resting and taking care of her basic needs is not normal. Unquestionably she is in a stressful situation with her children and son leaving to head south, but the additional physical stress atop the emotional and possibly spiritual stress she feels is just far too much for her to handle.

Additionally she completely ignores Rickon her youngest son who Robb noted was also confused and dealing with abandonment issues due to the departure of nearly all his siblings. Certainly these are the most trying of times for Catelyn, and she is unable to come to her senses until after she breaks down and awakens days later.

Indeed we see that she even regrets her behavior and vows to do better in this time of need. The question is going forward is will she be able to handle the stresses and pressure of the challenges that lie ahead?

For those of you keeping count we are up to 17 dead characters so far. Still a long ways from the Twitter Punchline of 140. This is also being generous and including the 12 Dothraki who died at Dany's wedding. Short them we are only up to 5 deaths and all so far have been minor characters. But it's a long way to go.

Game of Thrones Detailed Review: Prologue

Welcome to my chapter by chapter review of Game of Thrones. (Part of A Song of Ice & Fire by George R. R. Martin) If you haven’t read the novels or seen the HBO series this will be nothing but spoiler after spoiler for you.

If you have read the books then this will be a deeper look and I’ll be pointing out some things that may have been missed the first time through. I’ll also be pointing out some differences between the novels and the show. My goal is to get through all the books before George R. R. Martin releases the 6th book The Winds of Winter, by going over at least one chapter per week..

So without any further ado lets get started.

Game of Thrones Prologue

The Song of Ice and Fire starts out with three men of the nights watch out on patrol beyond the wall.

Left to Right: Gared, Ser Waymar Royce, and Will

Gared is an experienced ranger of 40 years. Will was a hunter and four years ago he got caught poaching by the men of Lord Mallister and opted to join the watch instead of losing a hand.

Ser Waymar Royce is 18 years old and the son of a noble family. Now in Westeros inheritance of titles and lands falls to the oldest male in the family. If no living male heir exists then it falls to the oldest female. Yes this does mean a womans younger brothers are in line before her when it comes to lands and titles. This is important to keep in mind as it’s a source of motivations for characters and is a reoccuring theme throughout the story.

But back to Ser Waymar, he has been given command of this patrol from Lord Commander Mormont. Waymar comes from money. His clothing, armor, the war horse he rides, not to mention the longsword made from castle forged steel with jewels in the hilt.

Essentially this is the most likely reason Lord Mormont gave command to Ser Royce. We know the Nights Watch has fallen on hard times. The wall isn't manned like it should be, there are literally castles and forts along it that are abandoned and crumbling. So knowing Ser Waymar comes from money, Mormont may have been hoping that after a few years Lord Royce might be swayed into making a donation to the Night's Watch. So Waymar gets command over the more experienced Will and Gared.

Now Waymar has two older brothers Andar who is the first in line to become Lord of Runstone and his 2nd older brother Robar. So it’s really unlikely he was gonna inherit the family lands and title. So going to the wall in a time of peace may have been a selfless act of service.

Just a little bit about House Royce; they are the sworn bannermen of House Arryn Lord of the Vale. They are a very old house and at one point ruled the vale until they were supplanted by House Arryn.

Coat of Arms of House Royce

The family words are “We Remember” which suggests they may have ambitions of returning the house to it’s former glory.

They are tracking a group of wildlings through the haunted forest. Will is reporting back after finding the camp of wildlings apparently dead from the cold. Gared who has been ranging beyond the wall for forty years agrees that it was the cold that killed them and even relates his own experiences with how dangerous it can be.

Ser Royce disagrees and wants to see for himself as he realizes it’s not cold enough to kill. They move closer and Gared and Will feel that something is amiss. Ser Waymar outwardly mocks the Gared calling him a fool for wanting a fire.

Long story short Will and Waymar get to the camp and the bodies of the wildlings are gone. Waymar orders will up a tree and we the readers have our first encounter with The Others, also known as the White Walkers.

Some things on The Others is that the temperature drops when they are around. So it gets really cold quickly. Also when they kill a foe they raise them up as a Wight which is what happens to Ser Waymar. In addition they are also incredibly stealthy. The armor seems to change color as it moves. In addition they make no noise as they move. Ser Waymar is taken completely unaware that he is surrounded by foes initially when he gets killed. On top of that they wear armor that changes color similar to the armor worn by the Predator in the movies. They also carry some sort of spectral blade that is stronger than steel. In addition the ringmail worn by Ser Waymar really doesn't offer a lot of protection as The Others spectral blades cut through it with relative ease. Ser Waymar’s blade shatters in the fight and he is killed.

Will who was up a tree looking for the wildings stays hidden out of fear and the others don’t seem to notice or care about him. When he gets down he snags up the broken sword. This is his sort of proof that Ser Waymar fell and he can bring this back to Lord Mormont.

Unfortunately Weymar rises up as a wight and strangles Will before he can make good his escape.

This just leaves Gared alive who wanted to build a fire but was forbidden to by Ser Waymar, and forced to stay behind and tend to the horses while Waymar and Will investigated the wildling camp. This might suggest that they can at least be kept at bay with fire. 

At the least Gared would have heard the piercing sounds of fighting between the White Walker and Ser Royce and that should have alerted him to the danger. Or perhaps the Others didn't care about Will and Gared and just wanted to kill Weymar as they didn't see to bother them.

TV vs. Book

This is the section where I will point out the differences between the book and the HBO series. I’m gonna leave out the minor differences like how in the book the three rangers are days travel from the wall and in the series they are shown leaving which suggests the walkers are a lot closer to the wall then they really are. I’m gonna let some of those things go as they most likely are done to make a smooth adaptation.

• In the TV series, Will discovers the wildlings massacred and their bodies brutalized. In the book, he says they appeared to be sleeping and likely froze to death.
• The White Walkers are of different appearance in the TV series. In the book, they have white skin and reflective light armor. In the TV series, they have frozen grey skin, dark hair, and a brutal face similar to a skull. They don't seem to wear any armor.
• In the TV series, Gared and Waymar Royce face the White Walkers' first attack, while Will is exploring the area. In the book, Gared is left a short distance away to protect the horses and Will is climbing a tree to get a visual on the wildlings while Waymar Royce was left beneath the tree to face the White walkers by himself.
• In the books, a group (at least five) of "the Others" (White Walkers) approach Ser Waymar Royce, who has a duel with one of them before finally being killed by the group. In the TV series not more than two White Walkers appear, and Waymar is killed in a surprise attack by one.
• The wight girl, who frightens Will in the series is never mentioned in the book.
• In the books, Ser Waymar Royce is transformed into a wight.
• In the TV series, Gared is the second one to be killed by the White Walkers and Will escapes. In the books, Will is strangled by the wight of Ser Waymar Royce and Gared escapes. There is a key difference in the fact that in the TV series the death is a beheading at the hands of a White Walker as opposed to being killed by a wight.